I’m just gonna say it: navigating bottle refusal royally sucks. It’s exhausting, stressful, and somehow manages to make you question everything, even though you’re doing your absolute best.
If you’ve landed here, I already know how hard you’re working, and how much you want feeding to feel easier, calmer… and less like a battle of wills with someone who still wears footie PJs.
In Part 1 of this series, we talked about how Your Baby’s Bottle-feeding Aversion isn’t the right fit for breastfed babies who are refusing bottles. This follow-up post is going deeper.
We’re going to walk through the four “Golden Feeding Rules” outlined in the book. These rules are the core of the method, and I’m going to show you exactly why they don’t work for breastfed babies who may still be learning how to bottle feed. In fact, when applied to breastfed babies with bottle refusal, these rules can actually make the problem worse.
Not because you’re doing the method wrong. Not because you’re not following the instructions carefully enough. But because these strategies were built for a completely different kind of feeding issue.
Let’s break it down.
The four golden rules of Your Baby's Bottle-Feeding Aversion
Rowena Bennett’s method is built around a very specific scenario: a baby who was fully or mostly bottle fed, then developed a feeding aversion after a negative or pressuring experience. To address that, she introduces four “Golden Feeding Rules”:
No pressure to feed
No sleep-feeding
Bottle-feeds only
Follow baby’s lead
If your primarily bottle fed baby now refuses because feeding became stressful, that’s bottle aversion and these rules may help you reframe feedings to teach baby that eating can be safe and comfortable.
But if your nursing baby just “plays with” a bottle and doesn’t seem to know what to do with it?
These same rules can actually make your bottle refusal problem worse instead of resolving it.
Rule #1: No pressure to feed
This one sounds good in theory. I’m totally on board with low pressure feeding!
But Bennett’s version of “no pressure” is really broad.
She says if your baby turns their head, closes their mouth, fusses, or rolls their tongue around the nipple, then these are signs that your baby is full (“satiety cues”) and you need to stop the feeding.
Her instructions are:
“As soon as baby turns his head away, closes his mouth, rolls his tongue around the nipple, or fusses or cries, stop the feed. Say, ‘I can see you don’t want to eat now. That’s okay. You can eat later.’ Remove the bottle and offer again after 5 minutes. If the same thing happens, the feeding is over. Wait at least one hour before offering again.”
The idea is that if a baby isn’t pressured, hunger will eventually bring them back to the bottle calmly.
But here’s the thing: most of those “refusal” signs are completely normal for babies who are still learning to bottle-feed. Especially breastfed babies. They’re not rejecting the bottle emotionally. They’re just frustrated and trying to figure it out.
If you end the feed every time your baby pauses or struggles, you’re not helping them avoid pressure… you’re taking away their chance to practice. You may even accidentally teach them that if they don’t do it perfectly right away, they don’t get to keep trying.
And THAT is a fast track to bottle aversion.
Then there’s this line from the book:
“Better to stop too soon than persist and create more negativity. Don’t worry, it won’t take him long to figure out he needs to take it when it’s offered without messing about.”
I mean… really? That sounds like the warning you get before your boss fires you.
It’s a different kind of feeding pressure dressed up as “choice.” And it doesn’t leave much room for babies who are trying their best but just haven’t mastered the skill of bottle feeding yet.
Rule #2: No sleep-feeding
This rule says babies should only be fed when they’re fully awake and alert. Bennett writes:
“Sleep-feeding does not resolve the problem that is causing him to not want to eat while awake. It provides only a temporary solution of making baby (and thus the parent) feel better at that moment. It is preferable to encourage baby to take his full requirement during the day while awake. You may be able to achieve this by offering the bottle more frequently or shortening the interval between feeds.”
She allows “sleep-feeding” (feeding when sleepy or asleep) only if your baby hasn’t taken in at least 14 ounces during the day—and even then, she says you should offer one sleep feed of just enough to meet that bare minimum of ounces.
Here’s the problem: for many babies who are struggling with feeding, sleepy feeds are the only time they can feed successfully. Their body relaxes. Their reflexes take over. The overwhelm fades into the background. And milk goes in.
Taking that away doesn’t fix anything. It just removes one of the only ways your baby might be able to feed.
Sleepy feeds aren’t cheating. They’re often a stepping stone. They give your baby a positive feeding experience with the bottle, and that matters.
Rule #3: Bottle-feeds only
This one is where I really start screaming into a pillow.
Bennett writes:
“For a baby with bottle aversion, hunger is your best ally. Without hunger there will be no incentive for your baby to want to eat. Feeding him by any other method will provide temporary relief from a hungry tummy but will do nothing to resolve his aversion to bottle-feeding because you remove his primary reason to accept milk from a bottle.”
Her recommendation: during the two week period when you’re following her program, only offer bottles.
No breastfeeding.
No cups, no spoons, no solids.
Just bottles.
And maybe that works for babies who were primarily bottle feeding and are now averse to bottles because something negative happened.
But for primarily breastfed babies? This approach is deeply problematic.
These babies aren’t avoiding the bottle because they’re emotionally distressed and you’re not letting them feel hunger.
Breastfeeding isn’t interfering with progress—it’s the one feeding method that’s still working.
Removing breastfeeding doesn’t teach bottle skills. It removes comfort, nourishment, and the one thing your baby relies on. And what does that leave you with? A hungry, confused baby who now has fewer tools to work with.
We don’t need to remove breastfeeding to teach nursing babies how to bottle feed. We need to support babies through learning both.
Rule #4: Follow baby's lead
This one sounds right… at first. I talk about responsive feeding all the time. Watch your baby. Don’t schedule feeds; your baby is a person and not a robot. Let them set the pace.
But Bennett’s definition of “following your baby’s lead” can veer off course quickly.
Bennett says that part of following baby’s lead is discouraging something she calls “conflicted feeding behavior”:
“Conflicted feeding behavior is best defined as a baby who sucks a few times on the bottle, then pulls away in an emotional state, then returns to the bottle, sucks a few times and again pulls away in an emotional state… and so on. If your baby demonstrates this type of feeding behavior, remove the bottle and offer again after a short break. If your baby still doesn’t feed smoothly, the feed is over. You might be surprised how quickly she figures out she had better eat when a bottle is offered or remain hungry for a little longer.”
Um… what?
That stop-and-start rhythm is extremely common in babies who are learning to do, well… anything. They aren’t conflicted. They’re practicing.
And if they’re trying to feed from a bottle and they pull off, take a breath, suck their hand, fuss or moan a little, try again? That’s not your baby just messing around. That’s effort. It’s clumsy and chaotic, but it’s part of the process.
Taking the bottle away because your baby isn’t doing it smoothly enough doesn’t reinforce their autonomy. It teaches them that unless they get it right on the first try, they don’t get to eat. That’s not following their lead. That’s quitting before they’ve had a chance to learn.
If you’ve read Your Baby’s Bottle-Feeding Aversion and found yourself thinking, “This doesn’t feel quite right for my baby,” you’re probably right.
If you tried to follow the method and things got worse? You didn’t fail. You were just using a tool meant for a completely different job.
These strategies were built for true bottle aversion in primarily bottle fed babies. They are not designed for breastfeeding babies who are “refusing” bottles.
When used with breastfed babies still trying to figure out bottle feeding, the Golden Rules can:
- Take away their chance to practice
- Eliminate the sleepy feeds that actually work
- Remove breastfeeding, their only reliable feeding method
- Turn a learning curve into a full-on aversion
Your baby doesn’t need a reset. They need support.
They need calm, low-pressure practice. Access to comfort. Space to experiment. And the message that trying counts… even when it’s messy.
You don’t need to starve your baby out to get them to take a bottle. You just need to figure out why the bottle is hard for them- and then teach them what to do.
And the fact that you’re reading this post means you’re already five steps ahead of everyone who keeps telling you “if he’s hungry enough, he’ll eat.”
Pat yourself on the back for that- you’re doing an AMAZING job.
———–
Feeling stuck?
You can read more of my blog posts on bottle refusal here:
www.rachelobrienibclc.com/blog/category/bottlefeeding
I also share helpful posts, tips, and a little humor on Instagram:
@rachelobrienibclc
And if you’re ready for personalized help, I offer one-on-one consults (virtual or in-person) where we’ll look at your baby, your feeding setup, and make a plan together that actually works. You can book a session here:
www.rachelobrienibclc.com/bottle-refusal
You’re not failing. You’re showing up. And you’re doing a damn good job.
Please note: This blog post includes Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase items through Amazon after following my links above, I earn 4% of the purchase price.
Like this article?
Leave a comment
subscribe to my blog!
I'll email you every time there's a new blog post. No spam. Pinky swear.